THH Playbook

Objection: Upcoming Court Date

The Challenge

Court dates create urgency and fear. The client is worried about legal consequences if they miss their hearing, or they're hoping the judge will be lenient without needing treatment. Your job is to reframe treatment as an advantage before court, not something that conflicts with it.

The Script

"We can transport you to the court date if you must be there in person. I would highly recommend taking action to help yourself before seeing the judge. The judge seeing a lot of people that have substance issues. I promise you they will be more likely at a reduced sentence for someone who has identified they have a problem and took the action to get help rather than just waiting to see what the judge says and demands."
Scenario: Client has upcoming court date

Why This Works

1. Remove the Logistics Barrier

"We can transport you to the court date" — You've just eliminated the practical objection. They don't have to choose between treatment and court. They can do both.

2. Position Treatment as Strategic

"I would highly recommend taking action to help yourself before seeing the judge" — This isn't about avoiding court. It's about showing up prepared.

3. Speak to Judge Psychology

"The judge is seeing a lot of people with substance issues" — Judges aren't impressed by promises to change. They're impressed by action already taken.

4. Create the Comparison

Someone who's already in treatment vs. someone who's waiting to see what happens — the judge will favor the first person every time. You're painting that picture without having to spell it out.

Follow-Up Moves

If They're Worried About Missing Court

"You won't miss court. We'll make sure you get there. But here's the difference: you can show up in street clothes, still using, with nothing to show the judge except promises. Or you can show up from a treatment facility, with documentation that you're actively getting help, with a clinical team that can testify to your commitment. Which person do you think the judge is going to be more lenient with?"
Scenario: Client fears missing court will hurt them

If They Want to Wait Until After Court

"I get it — you want to see what the judge says first. But think about this: what if the judge orders you into treatment anyway? Or worse, what if they give you jail time because you showed up with no plan? Right now, you have the chance to show initiative. You're saying, 'I recognize I have a problem, and I'm doing something about it.' That's powerful. That's what gets judges to show mercy. Waiting until after court to get help doesn't give you that leverage. And if the judge does order treatment, you're already ahead of the game."
Scenario: Client wants to delay until after court

The Documentation Advantage

Addressing Specific Court Situations

DUI / DWI Charges

"DUI cases are exactly when judges want to see treatment. You're basically proving their point — you have a substance problem. The question is whether you're going to fix it voluntarily or wait for them to force you. Judges look favorably on people who start treatment before sentencing. It shows accountability. And in some cases, treatment can be counted toward any court-ordered rehab. Let your lawyer know you're going — they'll use it in your defense."
Scenario: Client facing DUI charges

Drug Possession Charges

"Possession charges are different from dealing. The judge knows you're using. Going to treatment before court shows you're not a career criminal — you're someone struggling with addiction who's taking steps to get clean. That's the difference between rehab and incarceration. Judges want to see you're serious. And the best way to show that is to already be in treatment when you walk into the courtroom."
Scenario: Client facing drug charges

Probation Violations

"If you violated probation, the judge is going to be less forgiving unless you have a plan. Showing up to court already enrolled in treatment is your best shot at avoiding jail time. It's proof that you're taking responsibility. Your probation officer and the judge both want to see action, not excuses. Get ahead of this before your hearing."
Scenario: Client violated probation

What NOT to Do

  • Don't give legal advice: "The judge will definitely go easy on you" — you don't know that
  • Don't guarantee outcomes: "You won't get jail time if you go to treatment" — not your place to promise
  • Don't badmouth the legal system: "Judges don't care" — undermines your credibility
  • Don't encourage skipping court: "Just don't show up" — terrible advice and potentially criminal
  • Don't minimize legal consequences: Court is serious. Treat it that way.

The Tie-Down Close

After explaining the strategic advantage of treatment before court:

"So if we can get you to court and you show up with proof that you're already in treatment, the court date isn't a barrier — it's actually motivation to start now, right? When is your hearing? Let's get you admitted so you have at least a few days of treatment under your belt before you see the judge."
Scenario: Closing after court objection

Real-World Application

The court objection often reveals two things:

  1. Denial: The client thinks they can talk their way out of consequences without treatment
  2. Fear: The client is scared of legal consequences and using court as a delay tactic

Your job is to flip the script: treatment isn't a distraction from court — it's preparation for court. Judges, prosecutors, and probation officers all recognize treatment as evidence of accountability. And accountability is what reduces sentences.

The Urgency Angle

If the court date is soon (within 7-14 days), create urgency:

"Your court date is [date]. That means you have [X days] to show the judge you're serious. Even a week of treatment is better than showing up with nothing. But we need to get you in today to maximize the impact. The longer you're in treatment before court, the better it looks. Let's not waste time."
Scenario: Court date is coming up soon

When to Escalate

If the court situation is complex (mandatory sentencing, felony charges, probation violations with jail time pending), suggest they talk to their lawyer first, but position treatment as something they should start immediately while that conversation happens:

"This sounds like a situation where you should definitely talk to your lawyer. But here's what I can tell you: starting treatment now doesn't hurt your case — it only helps. Call your lawyer, let them know you're going into treatment, and ask how they can use it in your defense. But don't wait for the lawyer to give you permission. Take action now."
Scenario: Complex legal situation